Girl Crush

Summer Job Illustration Garance Dore 2010

Do you have a particular girl crush right now? Because I certainly do…

My sister and I both share a deep girl-crush-love for (Goddess Incarnate) Jessica Chastain, who — aside from being absolutely stunning and a Meryl Streep-level actor — loves animals, actually practices what she preaches, and her Manhattan apartment is to die for. (The fact that she owns decor items once belonging to Lauren Bacall — my sister’s and my earliest girl crush — really solidified our love for her.)

Jessica Chastain Ryan McGinley Porter Magazine 2016

Our feelings can easily be summed up as admiration, topped by a twinge of envy — essential components of a good girl crush, wouldn’t you agree?

YouTuber Jenna Marbles kinda nails it when she sums up the “three tiers of girl crushes” straight women commonly have:

First level girl crush is, “I love you” like “I wanna be your best friend.” […]


Second tier girl crush is “I love you a lot” kinda like “I wanna be you.” […]


And the third level of girl crush is “Given the right circumstances, I would make a scissor sandwich with you.”

I can’t speak for Kim, but I’m a solid Tier 1 in my love for Jessica Chastain. I think I tend to fantasize more about having cool, rich, awesome friends than I do about being cool, rich, and awesome myself. It’s certainly not for lack of wanting to be those things, but rather that I value good, strong female friendships above almost anything else — and who would say no to a few extra perks?

Sure, being Oprah sounds super exciting, but goodness, wouldn’t you rather be Gale — all the benefits and hardly any of the stress? I know I would!

The New York Times also had an article about the “girl crush” way back in 2005, though even then it was certainly “not a new phenomenon”:

[A] girl crush [is] a phrase that many women in their 20’s and 30’s use in conversation, post on blogs and read in magazines. It refers to that fervent infatuation that one heterosexual woman develops for another woman who may seem impossibly sophisticated, gifted, beautiful or accomplished. And while a girl crush is, by its informal definition, not sexual in nature, the feelings that it triggers — excitement, nervousness, a sense of novelty — are very much like those that accompany a new romance.

In the same NYT article, Helen Fisher, an anthropologist and author of Why We Love: The Nature and Chemistry of Romantic Love, says:

The brain system for romantic love is associated with intense energy, focused energy, obsessive things — a host of characteristics that you can feel not just toward a mating sweetheart. […] There’s every reason to think that girls can fall in love with other girls without feeling sexual towards them, without the intention to marry them.

As I navigate an adulthood where making friends has proven so much more difficult than I could have anticipated it would be while I was still in school, girl crushes have become more prevalent in my day-to-day life — with people I meet or already know — than it ever was before. And since I am happily married and haven’t had a crush on a man in over 8 years, those feelings seem to have funneled exclusively towards women with whom I would just love to be friends.

Some girls are just so cool, you know?


This whole topic reminds me of a situation I found myself in three years ago.

While at a two-day conference for work, I sat next to a pretty girl from Portland, OR. It wasn’t until near the end of our second day there that we struck up a conversation and I found her to be incredibly sweet and interesting; within no time I was feeling that excitement build, the same thing that happens with a romantic crush — so thrilled, in this case, to have made a friend.

After the conference ended, but before our respective flights, we decided to get some snacks and drinks nearby. After several hours of good conversation, we took a cab to the airport together and — despite needing to be in separate terminals — we found a spot near her gate to grab dinner.

I put my number in her phone, she put her number in mine.

As we parted ways with an enthusiastic hug, I felt so giddy having connected so quickly with someone — a rare occurrence for an introvert like me. (Making friends is really hard when you spend most of your time at home, it turns out.)

As I got settled on the plane, I pulled out my phone to send her a brief text, to wish her a safe flight and thank her for being such good company… only to find her number wasn’t there.

Did she forget to click “save” when she entered her phone number? Did she purposefully not put in her number and I just misread all these signs of blossoming friendship? I know I saved mine in her phone — perhaps she would message me?

Three years later, she never has and I still don’t know what happened. Is this was it feels like to be ghosted after a date?

Girl crushes with “real” people are, without question, a bit more emotionally fraught and challenging to navigate because there really is some potential to develop a friendship — and also have your platonic-heart broken.

For now, I’ll stick with dishing about the talented, intelligent, beautiful celebrities I’m feeling smitten for these days, like Jessica, who will never have an opportunity to ghost me after a conference in Vegas.

So what about you? Feeling any lady love for a particular gal these days — celebrity or not? Ever have your friend-wanting heart shattered by a “cool” girl? I’d love to know!

(Top illustration by Garance Doré [see my tattoo of this here!]; Jessica Chastain photos by Ryan McGinley for Porter Magazine, Ioulex for Flaunt Magazine, and James White for Piaget)

2 thoughts on “Girl Crush

  1. I distinctly remember my first girl crush. I was in the 4th grade, and she was in 5th. I didn’t know her, other than that she played a main character in the school musical we were all in. She could sing. She had dark beautiful thick hair I wish I had. And at the time, I was absolutely obsessed with her. I stared at her on the playground as she played with her friends. I walked past her to see if I could hear what she was saying. At the time, it was so utterly confusing. Was I in love? It didn’t feel like that. But it didn’t take long for me to realize that I didn’t want to be WITH her. I wanted to BE her.

    So I’m very commonly in the Tier 2 bracket. Sometimes I want to be my girl crush’s friends, but more often than not (Eva Green, Jessica Chastain, Lauren Bacall, recently Alicia Vikander…) I wanna *be* them.

    Maybe the closest I ever came to Tier 3 was in 1999 (thru like… 2006) with Angeline Jolie. I was beyond obsessed with her, the crush ran deep and hard. Ahh, the good old days. She’s still up there, but honestly a TRUE Tier 1. What a cool friend to have!

    Currently, my primary BIG Girl Crush is Gugu Mbatha-Raw. OB.SESSED. She’s so beautiful, and British, and I wish I was her, legit. <3

    But I love my girl crushes, they make monogamous married like so much more exciting! =D



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s